Shelter Island, NY Homes For Sale | MLSLI.com - Long Island Real Estate
Find the perfect home, schedule showing times and more!
Rentals
Commercial
Land
Sold Properties
Find the right Agent, Mortgage or Title Officer for you.
Buyer / Seller Resources
Mobile App

Shelter Island NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

15 Properties Found

The median home value in Shelter Island, NY is $774,000. This is higher than the county median home value of $341,500. The national median home value is $177,414. The average price of homes sold in Shelter Island, NY is $774,000. Approximately 33.77% of Shelter Island homes are owned, compared to 10.47% rented, while 55.76% are vacant. Shelter Island real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale. Commercial properties are also available. If you see a property you’re interested in, contact a Shelter Island real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Learn more about Shelter Island Real Estate.


Sort Results:
1 - 15 of 15 Properties Displayed
Refine Property Search
Page 1 of 1    Prev | Next
Farmhouse,  1 Family
Beds:
3
Baths:
2 Full
Lot Size:
~ 0.71 Acres
Development:
Center
Total Taxes:
$3,965
MLS#:
2890132
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active
Contact:
Linda McCarthy, REALTOR®, lindamccarthy@danielgale.com, 631-749-1155
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Step Back In Time To This Quaint, Beautifully Restored 3Br Farmhouse. Spacious Mbr Suite Plus 2 Bedrooms And Bath. Huge Rear Screen Porch & Enclosed Front Porch Add Living Spaces To An Already Roomy Formal Dr, Cozy Lr W/Fp & Eik. Detached Garage W/Studio & Separate 1 Br Apt For Rental Income Are A Bonus. Co-Exclusive.

Colonial,  1 Family
Beds:
4
Baths:
3 Full
Lot Size:
1 Acre
Development:
Hay Beach
Total Taxes:
$4,761
MLS#:
2884566
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active
Contact:
Linda McCarthy, REALTOR®, lindamccarthy@danielgale.com, 631-749-1155
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Gorgeous Location On The 14th Tee Of Gardiner's Bay Country Club For This 4Br/3Ba Home. Living Room With Fireplace, Den, Formal Dining Room & Eik. 2 Car Attached Garage. Room For A Pool.

Bungalow,  1 Family
Beds:
2
Baths:
2 Full
Lot Size:
100X0
Total Taxes:
$2,136
MLS#:
2869137
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active
Courtesy: Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Cozy Cottage Located In The Heart Of Shelter Island, Nestled Away Behind A Long Sprawling Lawn. Centrally Located Making It A Quick Drive To Either The North Or South Ferry, With The Deli, Bank, And All Else You Might Need Right Around The Corner. Home Features Two Bedrooms, Two Full Bathrooms And Eat-In Kitchen, All On A Spacious Half Acre Of Property.

Contemporary,  1 Family
Beds:
5
Baths:
3 Full/1 Half
Lot Size:
.875 Acre
Development:
Wheeler Canal
Total Taxes:
$7,800
MLS#:
2867839
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active
Contact:
Linda McCarthy, REALTOR®, lindamccarthy@danielgale.com, 631-749-1155
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Water-View, Protected Dock W/Easy Access To Open Water & Gunite Pool W/Surround Deck Accompany This Spacious 5 Br/3.5Ba Island Home. In The Silver Beach Area Of Shelter Island, The Open Living Plan W/Fp, Stainless & Granite Kitchen & Finished Basement With Gym And Media Room Provide Comfort And Space For Summer Fun And Year Round Living.

Contemporary,  1 Family
Beds:
4
Baths:
2 Full/1 Half
Lot Size:
.52 Acre
Development:
Harbor View Acres
Total Taxes:
$3,454
MLS#:
2866736
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active
Contact:
Linda McCarthy, REALTOR®, lindamccarthy@danielgale.com, 631-749-1155
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Surprising, Frank Lloyd Wright-Inspired Contemporary In Private Community W/Deeded Beach & Mooring Rights. Spacious Light-Filled Open Living Area, Well-Crafted Unique Architectural Features, Living Room W/Fireplace, 3 Bdrms+ Lg Den, 2.5 Baths, Incl Master Bdrm Suite W/Sliding Glass Doors To Enclosed Mahogany Patio, In-Ground Heated Pool W/Landscaped Brick Poolside Deck.

Farmhouse,  1 Family
Beds:
5
Baths:
2 Full/1 Half
Lot Size:
226X
Development:
None
Total Taxes:
$4,298
MLS#:
2860446
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active
Contact:
Margaret Colligan, REALTOR®, margaretcolligan@danielgale.com, 631-749-1155
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Contemporary,  1 Family
Beds:
4
Baths:
3 Full/1 Half
Lot Size:
.5 Acre
Development:
Chase Creek
Total Taxes:
$8,028
MLS#:
2857365
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active
Contact:
Linda McCarthy, REALTOR®, lindamccarthy@danielgale.com, 631-749-1155
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Open House: Sunday, 12/11 11:00-1:00PM

Unique Ralph Kast Waterfront With Dock, Waterside Pool & Patio. Close To Heights Shops & Restaurants. Water-View Master Br Ensuite Plus 3 Guest Bedrooms, 3.5 Baths, 9 Skylights & Varied Decks For Entertaining. 2 Car Garage. A Superb Summer (Or Year Round) Setting!

Traditional,  1 Family
Beds:
4
Baths:
3 Full/1 Half
Lot Size:
.92 Acres
Total Taxes:
$9,000
MLS#:
2857107
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active

This Lovely New Built Home Offers 3800Sq Ft With An Open Floor Plan. This 4 Bedroom 3.5 Bath Home Offers 2 Fireplaces, Chef's Kitchen W/Ss Appliances And Stained Wood Floors Throughout. The Backyard Offers A Fireplace For Ambiance On Those Cold Fall Evenings, In Addition, A Saline Heated Pool With Waterfall And Cabana With Expansive Patios. Great Home For Entertaining.

Contemporary,  1 Family
Beds:
2
Baths:
1 Full/1 Half
Lot Size:
1.1 Ac
Total Taxes:
$4,163
MLS#:
2857104
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active

Renovated Menantic Creek Front Home With 180' Deepwater Dock. This Home Offers Furnished Open Living Space With Waterview, 2 Bedrooms, 1 Bath And Loft Area On 1.1 Acres With Separate Studio/Office And Gunite Heated Pool. Excellent Location For Summer Or Year Round On Quiet Road.

Estate,  1 Family
Beds:
3
Baths:
3 Full/1 Half
Lot Size:
1.16
Total Taxes:
$22,376
MLS#:
2853950
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active
Contact:
Wayne Marciano, REALTOR®, waynemarciano@danielgale.com, 631-692-6770
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Agency Inc

Classic Waterfront On Little Ram. Peter Pennoyer Design. Situated Above Coecles Harbor, Enjoy The Afternoon Sea Breeze And Stunning Harbor Sunsets. The Meticulous Home Features A Decorators Interior, Superb Millwork, Oversized Living Room, Chef's Kitchen, 3 Ensuite Bedrooms. Plus Guest House W/ Lg Bedroom And Bath. The Perfect Island Retreat! 110 Ft Dock And Beach.

,  1 Family
Beds:
4
Baths:
4 Full/1 Half
Lot Size:
.37 Acre
Development:
The Hedges
Total Taxes:
$6,832
MLS#:
2845047
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Waterfront Modern At Water's Edge With Dock, Waterside; Wrap Around Dining Deck, Pergula + 2nd Floor Verandas In Private Bucolic Setting. Quiet + Across From Large Waterfront Preserve. Spacious, Stylish + Recently Renovated, Italian Custom Cabinetry, Open Kitchen, Dr, Lr Have Doors To Deck + Dining Al Fresco. 2 Roomy Dens, Gym, Man Cave/Shop, New Roof + Skylights In 2014.

Post Modern,  1 Family
Beds:
3
Baths:
2 Full/1 Half
Lot Size:
.92 Acre
Total Taxes:
$4,555
MLS#:
2841151
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active

Newly Built Sun-Filled 2-Story Home Overlooks Landscaped Property Lush Woods W/ Water Views Room For Pool+Tennis Court. Soaring Foyer Entrance. Lr W/ Fireplace+Outdoor Deck Mbr Suite On Ground Fl, All Brs W/ Outdoor Decks. Walls Of Windows Watch Sunrise+Sunset. Blondwood Floors Ss Appliances Brushed Chrome Fixtures Granite Countertops In Kitchen. Walk To Beach, Restaurants

Ranch,  1 Family
Beds:
2
Baths:
1 Full
Lot Size:
1.7
Total Taxes:
$3,316
MLS#:
2828181
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active
Contact:
Christine Beckwith, REALTOR®, christine.beckwith@elliman.com, 631-298-8000
Courtesy: Douglas Elliman Real Estate

This Listing Is A Very Rare Find Because The Property Has Front Yard And Backyard Water Views On 1.7 Acres Along With A Beach Lot That Is 25Ft Wide X Approx. 118Ft Long Located On Peconic Ave.

Traditional,  1 Family
Beds:
4
Baths:
3 Full
Lot Size:
1.10 Acre
Development:
Wade's Beach
Total Taxes:
$4,440
MLS#:
2770167
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Stone's Throw From Lake, Down The Street From Public Beach. Secret Garden Hideaway On A Level Hill Top Acre+ With Mature Gardens, Gazebo, Wrap Around Dining Deck, Fenced, Private, Heated, Slate Surround Gunite Pool + Lawn To Play On. The 2 Owner's Suites, Sole Upstairs + Main Floor Also Boats 2 Additional Guest Rooms, Finished Den On Lower Level With Walk Out 2 Car Garage

Traditional,  1 Family
Beds:
3
Baths:
3 Full/1 Half
Lot Size:
1.92 Acre+
Development:
Peconic Bay
Total Taxes:
$7,214
MLS#:
2685460
Type:
Single Family
Schools:
Shelter Island
Status:
Active
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

Beautiful Sunsets From This Waterview Compound. The Main 3+ En Suite Bedroom Shingle Traditional With Pool Is Landscaped With Mature Plantings. There Is Also Sandy Beachfront Property + An Adjacent Wv Lot That Make Up This Move In Ready Bucolic Retreat With Many High End Extras Including Waterside Roof Gazebo, Den + Additional Parlor.

Refine Property Search
Page 1 of 1    Prev | Next
1 - 15 of 15 Properties Displayed

How may I help you?

Get property information, schedule a showing or find an agent





We respect your privacy